Sensible legislation on stem cells
Michigan's Catholic parishes are sending DVDs and other material to more than 500,000 homes encouraging Catholics to support research on adult stem cells but to reject the use of stem cells taken from embryos. It's a nuanced and honorable stance grounded in faith. It's also one we question.
Embryonic stem cells appear to have great potential for research and to combat many diseases. State lawmakers have discussed allowing couples to donate their unused embryos from in-vitro fertilization - embryos that would otherwise be destroyed - for such research. We see no reason not to do that if it might help save lives.
The distinction between research on adult and embryonic stem cells is subtle but important. Both hold tremendous promise to save lives, and that's why stem-cell research has drawn such attention. Adult cells, however, are more difficult to grow and are limited in what types of cells they can become; adult stem cells drawn from blood can grow only into blood cells. Embryonic cells are prized for their "plasticity'
The real issue is one of conscience. Some faiths compare the destruction of an embryo to the taking of a life. That relies on a belief that even the tiniest creation - a few cells, really - deserves protection. It's fair to raise the broader question of morality: If one is willing to sacrifice a few cells, where will we draw the line? Is society stepping down a slippery slope?
The reality, however, is that these embryonic cells don't feel, suffer or have even the faintest consciousness. And most fertility clinics destroy unused embryos, an accepted practice. Why, then, not put them to use for potentially life-saving research?
State lawmakers haven't considered spending public dollars for stem-cell work, as California's voters did two years ago, but lawmakers are talking about giving couples the chance to contribute their unused embryos that would otherwise be destroyed. That is a very limited use of embryonic stem cells, and we think it makes sense.
Jackson Citizen Patriot
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch format to Traditional
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe
__,_._,___
